Blog

Potential analysis for effective leadership development: Identifying and specifically promoting future skills

Führungskräfteentwicklung

How can leadership development be achieved in a way that is not only well-received but actually makes a difference? Why a thorough potential analysis should be the starting point and what competencies leaders need to meet future challenges.

Companies invest considerable time and money in developing their leaders. Training programs are designed, external experts are hired, and development initiatives are implemented with great dedication. Feedback is often positive: participants were motivated, the content was engaging, and the event was well-organized. But six months later, a crucial question arises: What has actually changed? Are the skills taught being applied in everyday leadership practice? Have certain behaviors evolved? And are the leaders better prepared for their roles today than before?

This is precisely where it becomes clear what is important for effective [action/performance]. Leadership development The key is that success is not determined by a single measure, but by the interplay of a sound analysis, individual development goals, suitable learning formats and consistent practical application.

What makes leadership development truly effective?

Research also shows that it is worthwhile to take a closer look at the design of development programs. Lacerenza et al. (2017) conducted a comprehensive meta-analysis to investigate the conditions under which leadership training is particularly effective. They evaluated 335 independent samples for this purpose.

The result: Leadership training can indeed have positive effects on learning, the transfer of knowledge to daily work, and results within the company. However, the crucial factor is how the programs are designed and implemented. Four key areas for success can be derived from the results:

  1. A thorough planning and needs analysis. The starting point should always be the question: What competencies do our managers actually need? A clear needs analysis forms the basis for concrete development goals. Equally important is understanding the individual starting point of each participant. Not every manager possesses the same strengths or requires the same support. Therefore, instead of a one-size-fits-all development program, a differentiated approach is necessary. Various methods and tools, as well as regular feedback opportunities, help to identify development needs and tailor the process accordingly.
  2. A suitable implementation. The method of implementation also plays a role. The meta-analysis suggests that trainer-led, face-to-face formats and the combination of different learning methods can be particularly effective. The focus should not be solely on imparting knowledge. It is also crucial that managers can observe, try out, and practice new behaviors.
  3. A training structure that enables transfer. A single seminar day can provide important impetus. However, it is often insufficient for lasting change. Learning units spread out over time offer the opportunity to apply new insights to one's daily work between sessions. Several sessions, rather than a single, intensive block of training, create space for experience, reflection, and repeated experimentation. The time between sessions thus becomes an integral part of the learning process itself.
  4. A supportive organizational framework. Last but not least, the framework conditions also influence success. Clear expectations, binding participation requirements, and sufficient time for development are important prerequisites. Managers need the opportunity to engage with the content and actually monitor its implementation in their daily work.

The key finding: Effective leadership development is not a one-off event. It is a structured process that begins even before the first training session and extends far beyond it.

Development begins with a location analysis: Where do we actually stand?

In addition to methodological success factors, it is worthwhile to consider the people who are to develop. Because even at an individual level, there are prerequisites that determine whether development can succeed.

Three aspects are particularly important:

  1. Motivation: Is there a willingness to develop? Change requires that a person is willing to examine their own behavior. How important is it to them to develop further in a particular area of competence? Do they recognize a need for development themselves? And are they prepared to invest time and energy in this process? If this willingness is completely lacking, even well-designed measures will struggle to be effective. Therefore, the motivation for development should be addressed early on.
  2. Fit: Where do individual strengths and areas for development lie? Not every measure is equally suitable for every person. A development measure should neither disregard existing skills nor impose demands that are currently too far removed from the individual's capabilities. Development is particularly effective where people are challenged but not permanently overwhelmed. The key is to identify the individual's development zone: What competencies are already present? Where are there concrete starting points? And what are the next realistic and sensible development steps? A thorough potential analysis helps answer these questions and tailor support specifically to the individual.
  3. Orientation: Do I know where I stand and what I need? Self-reflection is a crucial prerequisite for personal development. Leaders must be able to recognize and assess their own behavioral patterns, strengths, and challenges. This requires opportunities for reflection and constructive dialogue. Structured feedback sessions, diagnostic assessments, and examining one's self-image and how others perceive oneself provide orientation. Only when it is clear where someone stands and where their development should lead can appropriate measures be derived.

How a sound potential analysis supports the development process

To translate these insights into concrete development steps, a comprehensive and meaningful assessment of the current situation is essential. This is where aptitude diagnostics comes into play. It enables the systematic identification of job-relevant competencies, personal resources, and individual development areas. The explicit goal is not to pigeonhole people. Rather, it aims to highlight strengths, provide a differentiated analysis of development needs, and facilitate well-informed decisions regarding further support.

Depending on the question and required competence, different diagnostic procedures can be used:

  • Cognitive performance tests: They assess, for example, reasoning skills, problem-solving abilities, or concentration skills.
  • Structured Interviews: They enable a targeted examination of previous experiences, specific behaviors, and individual assessments.
  • Personality analyses: They provide insights into job-relevant personality traits, motives, and individual behavioral preferences.
  • Practical exercises and simulations: Case studies, role-playing exercises, or presentation tasks allow us to observe how people act in specific professional situations.

 

A potential analysis becomes particularly insightful when different methods are combined. Different methods illuminate different facets of a competency, resulting in a more nuanced overall picture than any single method could provide. Crucially, the focus must always be on the requirements: Which competencies are relevant for the respective leadership position, and how can they be appropriately assessed? A requirements-exercise matrix can help systematically assign the necessary competencies to the appropriate diagnostic methods and exercises.

Ideally, by this point you will have already completed two important steps:

  • One Needs analysisWhat skills are needed today and in the future?
  • One Location analysisWhat strengths and areas for development do the managers in question possess?

 

The subsequent comparison of the current state and the desired state reveals where a good fit already exists and where targeted development is advisable. This gives you both the goal and the starting point. Now it's a matter of designing the right path in between.

From potential analysis to individual development plan

A good diagnosis alone does not guarantee development. The results must be translated into concrete, realistic, and individualized measures. An individualized skills development plan defines which skills should be strengthened, which steps are appropriate, and how progress will be recognized. Both individual prerequisites and organizational requirements should be taken into account.

Development measures can generally be divided into two areas:

On-the-job learning: Learning directly in everyday work

Development is particularly sustainable when new skills can be tested directly in practice. Possible measures include:

  • Taking on new projects or additional areas of responsibility
  • Peer consultation and regular exchange with other managers
  • Mentoring by experienced leaders
  • Targeted assumption of new tasks and roles

 

Off-the-Job: Targeted development formats outside of day-to-day business

In addition, structured development programs can provide important impetus:

  • Training for the teaching and practice of knowledge, skills and behaviors
  • Individual coaching for individual reflection and processing of personal challenges
  • Learning teams and Leadership workshops for working together on specific leadership situations

Which measure is appropriate always depends on the specific development goal. While training courses, for example, are particularly suitable for imparting knowledge and practicing certain behaviors, coaching offers space for individual questions and personal change processes.

The leadership workshop is a special way to closely link development with everyday leadership.

Developing practical skills: The leadership workshop

In a leadership workshop, the focus is not on a predetermined seminar topic or a fixed curriculum. Instead, the workshop operates on a pull principle: participating leaders contribute their own current challenges from their leadership practice. The topics thus emerge from the specific needs of the group.

In small learning groups, these cases are worked on, reflected upon, and further developed together. The goal is to address individual challenges in a targeted manner and to build behavioral skills sustainably.

Typical components of a leadership workshop include:

  • Working on concrete practical cases from the participants
  • Brief expert presentations on relevant leadership and communication topics
  • Peer case consultation and exchange of experience
  • Role-playing and video analysis to reflect on one's own behavior
  • Feedback from development facilitators and other participants
  • Additional individual coaching available if needed.

One possible format includes approximately five full-day meetings spaced four to six weeks apart. These are supplemented by self-organized learning team meetings.

What makes this format particularly effective? The intensive work in a small group, the high level of commitment, and the direct connection to one's own daily work are key advantages. This approach doesn't just focus on specific behaviors. Participants can also reflect on and further develop their own leadership style, personal values, beliefs, and underlying competencies.

Regular review meetings and evaluations further help to make progress visible and ensure the transfer of learning into daily practice. In this way, development is not only discussed, but actually tested and integrated step by step into leadership practice.

Future skills: Development must not stop with today's requirements.

If you are already working with a thorough needs and location analysis, creating individual development plans, and consistently supporting the practical application of these plans, you have created important prerequisites for effective leadership development. However, another perspective should not be overlooked: a look to the future.

Many companies primarily base their development programs on existing competency models and current requirements. This is understandable, as managers ultimately need to successfully manage their current tasks. However, the world of work is changing. Digitalization, artificial intelligence, new forms of collaboration, and increasing complexity are constantly altering the demands placed on leadership. The crucial challenge, therefore, is not only to close current competency gaps. Companies must also proactively develop the competencies they will need for future tasks and changes.

These so-called future skills – often also referred to as Future Skills described as – helping people to remain self-efficacious, community-oriented, critical, open and capable of action in a dynamic and complex working world.

Conclusion: Effective development begins with understanding potential.

Successful leadership development doesn't come from offering as many training courses as possible. What's crucial is that the right people work on the right skills – with appropriate methods, clear goals, and sufficient opportunity to apply what they've learned in their daily work.

This requires a combination of three perspectives:

  • Understanding requirements: What skills does the company need today and in the future?
  • Recognizing potential: Where do the managers currently stand? What strengths and areas for development do they bring to the table?
  • Targeted development planning: What individual measures enable sustainable changes and ensure their transfer into practice?

A thorough potential analysis provides the necessary guidance. It makes individual resources visible, identifies areas for development, and forms the basis for tailored development measures. And it opens up an important additional perspective: aligning development not only with what is needed today, but also with what will be crucial tomorrow. Because the greatest challenge is not closing current skills gaps, but recognizing future requirements early on and strategically developing the necessary potential to meet them.

Do you want to identify and develop leadership potential in a targeted way?

We support you in making a sound assessment of your managers' skills, identifying individual development needs, and deriving appropriate development measures.

Whether it's potential analysis, leadership development or the design of individual development programs: Together we will find out what your managers need today and tomorrow.

Feel free to contact us. We look forward to hearing from you!